Best New York Bagel Reviews

The bagels showed up on time, which was nice, but the packaging was just kind of average haha. The box had a small dent, and the bag inside didn’t feel as sealed up as I expected.
Nothing was damaged or ruined, so I’m glad about that. I just think for food delivery, it could’ve been packed a little more carefully. Not awful at all, just something that could be better.

I really wanted to like these, but the texture just felt off to me. The bagels were super dense and chewy, and not in that fresh, satisfying way. Toasting them helped a bit, but they still came out kind of tough. The flavor was alright, but it just wasn’t the bagel texture I was hoping for.

These bagels tasted close to what I remember from New York. A bit on the pricey side, but I treated myself and felt like I scored a small win for breakfast.

I was really looking forward to these bagels, but the crust kind of ruined it for me. The inside tasted fine, but the outside was so hard and a little dry that it just wasn’t enjoyable. Maybe I was already not in the mood to wrestle with breakfast, but this definitely wasn’t what I expected.

I really liked the flavor, but the portion felt small to me. Maybe it works as a light meal or snack, but I was still hungry afterward.

I had an issue with my order, they got back to me fast, and sorted it out quickly. It was a simple, easy experience, which I really appreciated.

I was expecting the usual delivery timeline, but this got here quicker than that. I tend to notice when shipping updates line up smoothly, and this one just moved through the steps without any weird delays. No complaints from me.

Checkout was fine overall, but wow, it felt way slower than it needed to be. I was just standing there dramatically wondering if I’d aged a full year by the time it finished.

I ordered a dozen from Best New York Bagel and stuck most of them in the freezer. Fresh, they were fine enough, nothing crazy, but once I reheated them they got really tough and kinda dry. I tried both the toaster and the oven, and even did the little splash of water trick, but the texture was still just off. For the price, I was hoping they’d hold up better. They’re not terrible bagels or anything, just not great if you’re planning to freeze them.

Got exactly what I ordered this time, which was a nice change, no missing bagels, no weird mix-ups, nothing. Happy overall. I just wish the pickup had been a little faster, but hey, at least the order was right.

I ordered from them and for the most part was just waiting around, checking emails, and trying to figure out what was going on. It wasn’t a huge disaster or anything, but it definitely dragged on longer than I thought it would. Customer support did eventually get back to me and the order issue was fixed, which I appreciated, but getting there was a bit frustrating.

Not gonna lie, I was impressed with my order from bestnewyorkbagel.com. The lox tasted super fresh, wasn’t overly salty, and they actually gave a good amount. The capers, onions, tomato, and cream cheese all worked perfectly together and made it feel like a real NY bagel. Nothing fancy, just really satisfying. I’d definitely order it again

I had a feeling these would be worth it, they pretty much proved me right. I ordered a dozen, and for the size and taste, the price felt totally fair. Shipping wasn’t bad either, which made the whole thing feel like an even better deal. The bagels showed up fresh enough and held up for a few days. Nothing overly fancy to say, but I definitely felt like I got my money’s worth and I’d order them again

I found everything so fast it almost felt magical. The site was super easy to navigate, and I didn’t have to waste a single second digging around. what a relief!

I sent a box from bestnewyorkbagel.com to my parents as a little weekend surprise, it went over really well. They’re picky about bagels, so I wasn’t totally sure what to expect, but they ended up really enjoying them.
The order arrived fresh and was packed nicely, which I appreciated because if you’re sending food to someone, it should show up the way you’d hope it would. My parents said it felt like a thoughtful treat, not just another random delivery showing up at the door.

If you know someone who misses New York bagels or just deserves a decent, cozy breakfast, this is a really sweet gift idea. I’d definitely order again for a birthday, holiday, or just to brighten someone’s weekend.

Just wish the shipping info was clearer. Like real dates. Actual updates. Not just a vague message. Hard to know when anything is coming...

I know it’s just cream cheese, but this one felt like a little win. It tasted good, seemed fresh, and did exactly what I needed it to do. Nothing overly fancy, just solid, tasty cream cheese showing up when it mattered.

I was disappointed with the bagels. Mine tasted dry and stale, like they’d been sitting out for hours instead of being fresh. I’ve liked this place before, but if this is the new normal, I’ll probably start going somewhere else

My pickup took way longer than expected, and the whole process felt unorganized. It had that feeling like there wasn’t a real person there keeping things moving or helping customers figure out what was going on.

I ordered from Best New York Bagel because they had a bunch of bagel flavors I don’t usually find near me. I’m usually a little cautious about trying food online since you never know if it’ll show up fresh or if the flavors will be hit or miss, but this ended up being a good experience. The everything bagel was really solid, and the cinnamon raisin was one of my favorites. My kids were into the blueberry one too. Not every flavor was amazing, but nothing felt like a waste either. Overall, I was happy with the order and would say it’s a nice option if you want something beyond the usual plain bagels.